I got it installed shortly after I made that post, I've just been too busy with work and other stuff to report back... Sorry.
It took 2 hours and 15 minutes total from start to finish. There's a lot of grease under my car. I got dirtier doing this job than I've ever been before. The kind of dirty where you take a shower and spend 20 minutes washing your hands so they're clean enough to wash the rest of your body, and you have to scrub your entire body with a bar of Lava. I still have grease under my fingernails from this job. I love it.
As far as the shifter goes, I love the new one. It feels nice and solid, and shifting is so much better now. Especially since everything is in reach, I don't have to stretch to get to 5th, and I can use my cigarette lighter to charge my phone while driving now.
Here are a couple of before and after pictures. Both are in 1st gear. I also put in some suede to match the headliner for the shift boot. I'm not sure I like the suede, so I may just order a black leather one.
before:
after: