Catalytic Converter Advice

stimmy

New Member
Messages
19
Likes
0
Location
Maine
#1
I'm new to the BMW community but anxious to dive in. I'm posting this message in two forums as I'm ignorant to both of their capabilities and prescence. I apologize for any annoyance I've caused with this, but I'd like to find a home, and the only way to do so is by correspondance, eh?

So, I just bought my first beamer. I had a Mercedes before ('84 300D) and fell in love with German manufacturing, but I did not realize the extent until I drove this car. It's a 1992 318iS that has been very very nicely maintained. There are a few minor imperfections, but they are mostly cosmetic. When I bought the car, I was warned that the catalytic converter was rusted, but hadn't yet show signs of malfunction. A few weeks later they started to.

A slight rattle at first turned into my baby sounding like it was Japanese and it's only gotten louder. So, it's about time to make a move. I checked out the heat shields, and one of them does need to be replaced, but the noise was coming straight from the cat. Now my question is multi-part:

a) What has my delay in fixing the cat done for harm to my car? Could it have hurt the oxygen sensor used for monitoring (the second one), and how do I test this?

b) Where can I locate heat shields at a decent price? Is Bavarian my best bet?


c) What should I look at for Catalytic Converts? I basically have four choices here, as far as I know, due to the fact that I definitely don't have the money for a stock one ($1,000 from Bavarian).

1. Aftermarket direct fit cat like http://www.all-catalytic-converters.com/bmw-318-converter.html which would run me about $250.

2. A name brand aftermarket direct fit, which I've yet to find.

3. A universal weld-on which I can have put on locally for $50.

4. A higher quality (high flow?) universal weld-on which I can either buy from the shop that puts it on, or order myself.

What I'm looking at here is a ratio of price to advantage. I'm honestly unaware of the difference in performance of the options, and I'd like any help/insight that anyone has to offer.

Thanks a lot!

James

ps. What differentiates between a Newbie post and one for the perspective forum (E36)?
 
Messages
2,469
Likes
0
Location
Desert Southwest
#2
I'll give 'em my best shot! [target]

a. The o2 sensor is probably shot, you can harm the muffler for delaying replacing the cat.

b. Not sure if Bav auto sells them, if they do, it would be close to dealer pricing. I suggest the dealer.

c. Look for a cat with all of the pipes, (i.e. nothing to weld). I really don't know of a "performance" cat. Bav Auto is showing one for $369 at the following link;
http://www.bavauto.com/shop.asp?HC1=0&HTarget=asgrid.asp&Hdept_id=61&Hecode=google

p.s. No real difference, just depends on where you think you may get the better/most responses.
 

stimmy

New Member
Messages
19
Likes
0
Location
Maine
#4
DrPierceMD: I'm near Bangor, why?

Vlad: Why, precisely, do you suggest the bolt on? We're talking about a difference of around $210 here, so I don't want to just guess. :) As per "performance" cats, I guess we'd mostly be talking about "high flow" ones? I'm sorry, I'm somewhat ignorant in this area.

I guess what I'm really asking is, are there any differences between the differn't cats you can get?

James
 
Messages
1,303
Likes
0
Location
Charleston, SC
#5
I would go with bolt-ons. and a high flow... there really isnt anything worth spending money on unless you are getting headders and maybe a new muffler. unfortunate that its all so expensive.

[welcome]
 


Top